Wednesday, February 17, 2010

"A Worn Path"

For homework today you need to watch the following video and post a comment answering the following questions:

After reading this story in class today, how does the video add to your understanding? Would do something similar for someone else, like Phoenix did for her grandson? Why, or why not?


75 comments:

  1. The video helps me to understand the stroy because it helps you visually see the surroundings and what the "path" truely looks like. I would definitely do something like Pheonix did for her grandson. If I really cared about the person I would go out of my way to try to make them feel better also.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Mrs. Lusher,
    So the video helps me understandd the time period and setting, and the distance she really walks.

    If i did something like Pheonix did for her grandson it would be for someone very close to me. You have to have dedication to do what she did, as often as she did it.
    **Christine Delgado, 9935147.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Charlotte Richardson


    The video makes certain things more obvious compared to when you're reading the story. For example in the text you actually believe that you're seeing a man at first when in the field. However in the movie it's clear that the figure is not a man and the old woman is just seeing things in her head.
    Yes I would do something like for someone I loved too, because if I were in the grandson's shoes I would of course want someone to bring me medicine.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The video put everything into a more realistic perspective. Yes, i would do something like this for someone that i greatly cared about because i would expect them to do the exact same thing for me if i was in a needy situation.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The movie enables the viewers, who read the story as well, to have a greater depth of understanding in the actual distance the woman travels to get the medicine for her grandson.The video overall creates a good picture of the story.
    I would do the same a Phoenix for someone I truly loved. As she said in the story, her grandson was all she had in the world and she would do anything to soothe his pain. If it meant saving something I cared for, no distance would keep me from helping.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The video helped me understand the story a lot better. When first reading the story it was harder to visualize what the scenery would look like, how the characters would look or act, or how long and difficult her trip really was.

    Yes, of course I would do something like that for somebody I really loved and cared about. I wouldn't want them to suffer, and if I had the power to help out I most definitely would, even though it would be hard for me.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The Video makes the story and the grandma's reasoning for her actions more realistic, and more understandable. Yes, i would try to do something like this for someone that i loved, because I would want to help them and because i would care about them. I think the journey would be worth it if it was going to really help someone.

    ReplyDelete
  8. the movie helped me visualize the trip and to understand what exactly phoenix was imagining and what was real. although her trip would frighten me at some points, i would definitely do this for a family member.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Watching this video helps me understand the setting, time period, how poor Phoenixs' conditions were, and how far she truely walked. And yes, i would do something like this because that's the right thing to do and i would want it done for me if i was in that situation.

    -9933630

    ReplyDelete
  10. Watching this video helped me see the setting, time period, how poor her conditions were, and how far she really walked. And yes, i would do something like this for someone because its the right thing to do and i would want it done for me if i was in that situation.

    -9933630

    ReplyDelete
  11. After seeing this clip, I can get a feel of the surroundings and characters in the story. The distance she traveled was greater than one would actually think when reading just the text.

    I would, without a doubt, did what Phoenix did. No matter if it is a love one or a stranger, I would do whatever to not make them suffer. Seeing a smile in their face makes me smile!

    ReplyDelete
  12. I honestly didn't fully understand the whole story line when reading this story in the readers book but now after watching this short film, I have a better understanding. I find things more understandable when I have the actual visual. I would most definitely find my way to help those who I loved whether it be travling miles on foot or doing whatever I had to. It's all about the car e and love for others.

    ReplyDelete
  13. 200264969-2nd period

    The video helps me to truly understand the hardships of her journey to get to town through the woods. It also helps to make certain parts in the story more easy to hear and visualize, such as the dialect and the time period.
    If someone that I loved and cared about with all my heart needed that medicine, I would go through anything in order to get it to that special someone, just like Phoenix.

    ReplyDelete
  14. This video shows what Pheonix had to go through and the true age of Pheonix.

    I would do anything like this for anyone i cared about.

    ReplyDelete
  15. The video helps you understand the story better by giving you a picture to look at and now you can see the characters interact with one another instead of visualizing it while you're reading the story, you get a better understanding when you read the story and then watch the movie because you already know what is going to happen in the video but you can see more clearly what the author was trying to make you visualize.

    Yes, I would do something similar to what Phoenix did for her grandson because that showed that she really cares about him and wants to help him and especially if it was someone dear to me I would do anything for them to help them out. So I can relate to Phoenix in this story.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Kaitlyn Winey
    Seeing this story as a video really helps me visualize the specific scenes. It also helped me realize how old Phoenix really was; in my head I pictured a totally different looking woman and scenery.
    Yes I would absolutely do something like Phoenix did for her grandson. If I had a friend or family member that needed my help I would do whatever it would take to help them, because I care about them.

    ReplyDelete
  17. By watching the video of "A Worn Path", It helped me cath on to things I didn't notice whie reading the story. I now vizualize the characters, setting, and most importantly the time period. I now see the "worn path" not just as a pathway through the woods to get to town, but the struggle and pain Phoneix goes through to help her grandson. The jourey to me would be more than worth it if it was to help someone in need.
    -Yvonne Locke

    ReplyDelete
  18. 200205037-3rd periodFebruary 17, 2010 at 6:18 PM

    The video showed me how long and far she actually walked just to get to town. Helped me understand the story better and the setting and time period of the story.
    Yes i would do the same thing as she did if i really cared about the person. I would help them in any way that i can.

    ReplyDelete
  19. The video makes the story alot more understandable and you can really put yourself in the Grandma's shoes. Also, I was surprised at what the Grandma could do for her age. Yes I would do the same thing for someone I loved and needed my help.

    ReplyDelete
  20. The video helped me understand the story more by putting a visual picture in my head. The video showed how old she really was and how far she had to walk. Reading the story didn't help me really put into perspective how much of a struggle it really was to get into town. If I were her I would do the same. She cared about her grandson greatly and I care about my family a lot too. I would help any way that I could because I love them and I want to help them. And I would hope they would do the same for me in return.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Kathryn Junco

    The video helped me to see the journey she took just to get to town, and it represented the time period well. Yes, i would do the same thing she did if i cared about someone's well being.

    ReplyDelete
  22. This video helped me identify the characters a lot more clearly as well as the surroundings. When reading I didn't really catch just how difficult it must of been for Phoenix to walk the worn path. The video did a good job depicting the difficulty of her task. I would definitely do what phoenix did for her grandson for anybody I loved and cared about. If I loved someone I would do anything for that person.

    ReplyDelete
  23. The video clarified the parts that I didn't understand reading the story. I didn't know if the dog attacked a man or what, and this helped me understand. Phoenix is a very strong and determined person to support her grandson like she does, and I would do exactly the same thing she did for a family member.

    ReplyDelete
  24. The video made everything into a better light, such as how far she had walked, how she reacted with that hunter and how she was in general. If there was someone in my life that means a lot to me then i would make a big journey like that even in a week condition such as that one.

    ReplyDelete
  25. This video shows how the struggle of Phoniex really was. It allows more visual insight into the path she traveled for her grandson it makes the story seems real & flows very nicely in the video. Whereas in the text you were more all over the place. It was a freshing view of modernist. I would do something like this for someone that I truly cared about, it would be tuff but extremly rewarding.

    ReplyDelete
  26. The video helped me understand the struggle she had during her journey to get to town in her old age. i saw how far she really walked and how hard it was for her. I would do something like that for someone that was very close to me and that i really cared about, like a family member or a very close friend.

    ReplyDelete
  27. This video gave me a more visual perspective of the story. It showed me how much she cared for her grandson to actually walk that long of way for him. It definitely helpped me understand the story better. If i cared and loved someone. i would do anything and everything to try to help that person out. Even if i have the sacrifice something that is dear to me i will for that person.

    ReplyDelete
  28. The video helped me understand the struggle she had on her journey to town in her old age. It helped me understand how far she really traveled and how hard it was for her. I would do something like that for someone close to me that i really cared about, like a family member or a really close friend.

    ReplyDelete
  29. The video helped me understand by seeing how far she traveled and how difficult the path was. It also helped me visualize the town and time period. I would do something like pheonix if I cared about the person because I would like to do whatever I could to help.

    ReplyDelete
  30. This video brings the story to life. It makes it easier to picture what the old woman looks like an everything.I would do the same thing that Phoenix did, if it was also for someone that i loved and cared about.I think that it is worth the trip to make someone smile.

    ReplyDelete
  31. "A Worn Path" made me think how far a person would travel just to get medicine for somebody they really cared about. The movie helped me understand the setting of the story and the conflicts Phoenix went through to retrieve the medicine. I would help somebody I care about to get them what they need to survive.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Though the video was short it helped me further grasp truly what sacrifices Phoenix makes for her grandson. Also, it gave me a better understanding of the time period and characters.

    I would do something like that for someone close to me. Sometimes you have to make sacrifices for people you care about, Phoenix being a great example of that.

    ReplyDelete
  33. This video helps me understand the story better by showing me these written characteristics come alive by an actor. The seemingly thoughtless actions like talking to oneself and non-human things that elderly people show is perfectly represented as it was told in the story. Her age, weakness, and mental strength are much more evident in this video. The prejudice can be seen first hand and makes this story much more believable and interpretable.

    If I were in her situation, and at that time, I probably would make a journey because it's for a friend or family member. It'll mean a whole lot more to me to see them get better than for me to get shot or something.

    ReplyDelete
  34. 9903542 4th

    This video gives me a more clear mind of what the stories settings, time period, and helps me understands the story more and how she tries to get the medicine for her grandson. She seems like a women that isnt afriad of nothing and wont let anyone tell her what to do.
    I would most certainly do something like what Pheonix is doing. If i had a family, friend, or a loved one then i would do whatever i could to help them get better. Mainly because i would want them to return the favor when im in that situation.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Watching the video, I was able to vizualize things the story could not show me. I would do such a thing for a loved one, I would go to any length becasue I would want them to be well.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Hey Mrs.Lusher.
    The video helped give me a visual and was less boring then the story in class. It gave a good visual of the old lady and showed the stuggles she was going through just to go to town. I might do something nice like that for a friend. Because, doing things like the old lady did shows how much you appreciate someone and the struggles you'd go through just to do something nice for them.
    Brianna Moring (5th period)

    ReplyDelete
  37. The video helps me understand the surroundings more. While reading it in class, I had imagined it much different than how it was portrayed in the video. I also never realized exactly how old the woman was and how much trouble it was for her to go to town from her house. If I had a grandson, I would definitely do any thing I could to help him, even if it meant hiking through the woods in my old age and stealing from people.

    ReplyDelete
  38. 200190634- 4th periodFebruary 17, 2010 at 8:39 PM

    this video really helped me visualize the story in the time period and how long she really walked. I would only walk that far for someone i loved and cared for like a family member, or a friend.

    ReplyDelete
  39. watching the scene showed me the actions where i counldnt really picture it in the story with words.maybe it depends on the person.out of duty

    ReplyDelete
  40. Seeing the sotry helps me to physically view what is happening, and all the minor details make it more simple, creating a clearier picture within the mind of the viewer. It also shows the actual great lenght that she travled to get to her grandson. I would love to do something like that for someone. It would mean a lot to me and them and I would do it because i would want it to be done for me if I was in a time of need.

    ReplyDelete
  41. The video helped me understand the setting and the challenges she went through. In the story I didn't understand what was happening with the man in the woods but, the video helped me understand it. I would do what Phoenix did for her grandson to someone important to me. If I really care for someone I will help them by all means.

    ReplyDelete
  42. This video really brings out the scenery in helping you better see the picture that the author was trying to create. This particular video really gives a vision of the path and what all went on.

    And yes I would do something similar to what she did for her grandson, because when you love someone you would do anything for them, even when you don’t know how or knowing you cant. In these things it’s the thought that matters most.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Watching the video really helped me see what happenend in the story. Hearing the reading really confused me by what was going on and it helped clear up what was happening

    Yes, I would go do something like that for someone I really cared about because I wouldn't want to let them down and i'd really want to help them out.

    ReplyDelete
  44. The video really helped me to understand her faith in herself to get the drugs home safely to her grandson. The amount she walked was no walk down the block, for Phoenix it was a long journey she had to make often because of the happiness & well-being she wanted her grandson to have. She gives up everything for her grandson.... her time, her health, and her money. Kathleen Brooks 5th

    ReplyDelete
  45. I think watching helped me in understading the setting of the story. It also helped me to understand what great lenghts she took in traveling such a far distance.
    Yes, I would do as Phoenix did for a loved one because I would want a loved one to do for me.
    Even though it was a long trip, it was for a good, selfless cause.
    Ashia Brown

    ReplyDelete
  46. 9914708-4th

    The video helped show the determination of Pheonix and how strong her will to help her grandson really is. If I were in a similar situation I would do the same thing, because I care about my friends and family. They are the most important things to me.

    ReplyDelete
  47. 200167503"4"

    The video really helps to bring her character to life, with all of the oddities associated with aging. The setting, the mood, and the character representation are excellent to properly imagine the story. It helps the understanding because certain actions are difficult to put to words and seeing it be acted out solidifies it.

    It depends on how much I care for the person, but if they were really important to me, I would do as much as I possibly could for them.

    ReplyDelete
  48. This video helped me visual the characters, plot, and setting. I now have a better understanding of the story. It was a little bit confusing to read in class. This video definitely helped

    ReplyDelete
  49. After watching the video, i got a better understanding of the rough journey that the main character had to go through. It was a bit sad to watch as she went so far for her grandson. I would do something like what Phoenix did for someone i loved, because i want to be there to help those close to me.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Katie McLaughlin-3rd

    This video helps me visualize the setting better and her character. It shows the struggle that she went through, and just how old she was. You can hear it was a struggle for her from the tone of her voice.
    I would do the same thing for someone else because I love them and I don't mind walking for them. It's just humane to do things like this for other people.

    ReplyDelete
  51. The video helped me really see the extent of Pheonix's frailty.
    If I was in a situation similar to her's, I can only hope to have that amount of hope and love she had.

    ReplyDelete
  52. Hello Mrs.Lusher,

    The video helped me visualize the character of Phoenix better by giving her a voice to go along with her description.I would do the same or more for someone I love because that would be to show them how much I love and care for that person like Phoenix for her grandson.She not only said she loved him,she proved it.

    ReplyDelete
  53. The movie added detail to the text. I did not picture Phoenix looking the way she appeared in the movie. The movie gave the viewer a in depth detail of the story. The story allows the reader to view the situation and the characters any way they want. I would do the same thing thar Phoenix did depending on who the person was. I would have to like them. It could not just be an ordinary person

    ReplyDelete
  54. Clinique Brooks
    The video helped me to make a story in my head.When we read the story in class it was confusing.
    Yes, I would like to do something like that for someone I really cared about because I would not want to let them down.

    ReplyDelete
  55. The video helps me to understand Pheonix and her age and how far she really went to help her grandson. It also gave me a better idea of the time period and setting. The video helped a lot because I am a very visual person. I would not do this kind of thing for just anyone but if I truely cared about someone I would.
    9947781

    ReplyDelete
  56. The video helped me understand the distance Pheonix walked and how bad her physical condition was and how difficult it made her walk. I would help someone close to me. If I truly cared about someone I would try my hardest to help and support them.

    ReplyDelete
  57. When reading the book it was easy to understand the main plot of why Poenix was traveling into town. This video just made things easier to understand. For example when Phoenix is in the fields, and sees a "man", the video actually explains that the figure is a scare crow. Little details like that, are not as easily portrayed.
    If I were in a situation where I could help someone I would. But I would go above and beyond for special people I cared about. If they are a big impact in my life, than I should have enough in my heart to do only as they would do for me.

    ReplyDelete
  58. This video helped me understand the story a little better. When we read it I got lost and a little confused at certain parts. Seeing what she was actually going through and how hard she was working made it that much more realistic.

    I would definitely do this for someone. Someone I cared for dearly. It'd be very difficult, especially at her age to do something like that. I'd like to say I would have that integrity also

    ReplyDelete
  59. Bryan Wozniak
    2200303771
    the video goes by in a more comprehensible way where you can hear and see the tone of the story. it also shows Phoenix's age so it puts it into perspective how hard the journey is but that she makes it anyway out of love for her grandson who would die without her edfforts and love.

    ReplyDelete
  60. Kyara Buchanan
    6th period
    The movie showed more details and gave me a better understanding of the story. It shows what some people would do to keep a close family member close.Phenox was very brave for an old woman and she is also wise.It's kind of sad nut interesting!

    ReplyDelete
  61. well i thought the story it self was a good representation of how far someone would go for their loved one. this video doesnt really help understand the story any better, because one the video quality is horrible and the two the actors are below average actors to me. if it was a rando person i probably wouldnt help them thats me. but if someone i knew well was in trouble i tried to help them to the best of my abilities.

    ReplyDelete
  62. Paul Kim
    5th Period
    The video helped me to visualize Phoenix, character better because of the background she walked. I would do the same for someone
    because if I really love someone, I will sacrifice myself to do whatever I can.

    ReplyDelete
  63. The video really helps you gain an understanding of the situation Phoenix was in. It shows the commitment and love that family members can have for each other. I think that I would do the same thing if I wee in the situation of I really loved the person. i certainly would want someone who loved me to do it for me.

    Coty Nash
    5th Period

    ReplyDelete
  64. 9932980 2nd period

    although the video added a lot of imagery the story gave me a better idea of what was going on.

    i could see my self doing something along those lines but that's not really saying much because it would be a bit easier for a high school student to do that.

    ReplyDelete
  65. "9933328" 4th periodFebruary 18, 2010 at 8:10 PM

    the video helped me uderstand the hunter's reaction to Phoenix more and helped me visualize the setting better. yes i would do something like that if someone really needed it and i loved them.

    ReplyDelete
  66. The video revealed more emotions than i expected and made the point of the story clearer. It helps me to understand with the video because it clear up ideas. I would go to extremes to save the life of a loved one.

    ReplyDelete
  67. The story is a really good example of how far someone would go for their loved ones and the video,actually seeing it,helped me understand the story as well as the characters better.

    I would most certainly do something liek this for someone I loved. I would stop at no ends to keep my loved ones safe and happy.

    ReplyDelete
  68. This video cleared up any misunderstanding there was during the reading. You can truly see the struggle she had journeying on the path. A visual is always useful when trying to understand something. If in the right scenario I would do the same as Phoenix had done for her grandson. Why? Because you shouldn't see someone struggle and not give a helping hand.

    ReplyDelete
  69. This video truly helped me alot to understand the story because I didn't understand the whole plot when I read in the book. I would like to do the same thing just as he did to his grandson because I feel same way as he did!

    ReplyDelete
  70. 200191820 period 3 billyFebruary 19, 2010 at 9:29 AM

    this video was sorta long but it did help me understand the story more clearly. although i didnt really like the story at all. but thank you for this video it made things more clearer.

    I would walk a thousand miles for someone i loved. So yes i would because i am a nice guy.

    ReplyDelete
  71. Since it was visual and not a word we had to read, it helped me understand the story much better. I have never done those long walk for anyone. I wonder how much she loves her grandson. Even though I did for no one, I wish someone do it for me if it is necessary.

    ReplyDelete
  72. This video really helped my understanding of the novel because it gave me a better understanding of the setting and the traits of the characters. I would walk that far for someone i care about if it helped them. In the long run it would help you become a better person.

    ReplyDelete
  73. 200250371 - 5th

    this video helped on the understanding of the story. It shows the great love the woman has for her grandson and walking such a great distance just to get some aid.it also helps see the time and place (setting) that it was at. very good on the images that were shown.

    ReplyDelete
  74. After reading this story in class, the video helps me understand it better because it actually lets me visualize what is happening. The video makes the story way more clear to me. I would do something similar to what Pheonix did for her grandson, because I would do anything for my loved ones.

    ReplyDelete
  75. Watching this video helps me understand the setting, time period, how poor Phoenixs' conditions were, and how far she truely walked. Yes, I would do this for someone it helps to build character and it shows you put others before yourself, which is very important.

    ReplyDelete